In an attempt to solidify their relationship, Justin reportedly proposed to Selena twice before they broke up. Should she have said yes? Justin Bieber took advice from Beyonce and allegedly tried to put a ring on it — the “it” being Selena Gomez. Unfortunately, the former Disney star wasn’t ready to walk down the aisle. Justin, 18, reportedly proposed to Selena, 20, a few months ago, but she said no, according to Blind Gossip. Selena allegedly told him to ask her again in a few months — he did, but she still said no. News of Justin and Selena’s split broke on Nov. 9, sending fans into a tizzy and erupting various break up theories including trust issues and Miley Cyrus! “They have agreed to never, never, ever talk about the proposals! It would be far too damaging to his reputation if people found out that a smaller star turned down a bigger star,” the website reports.